Politics

Why your Tucson electric bill is going up Dec. 1

Tucson Customers will pay about $150 more a year starting Dec. 1. Attorney General Kris Mayes says the decision favors TEP’s investors over ratepayers.

Bills and money.
Photo courtesy of Pexels.

The Arizona Corporation Commission voted 4-1 Nov. 17 to approve a rate hike requested for Tucson Electric Power. TEP residential customers can expect their electric bills to rise by about 9.4% starting Dec. 1, roughly an extra $150 per year, according to the commission.

TEP originally sought a bigger increase: about 14%, or roughly $16 per month for its customers. The utility group said it needed the money to cover grid investments, including new infrastructure and equipment, along with ongoing maintenance.

“We know that any increase matters to our customers,” said Susan Gray, the utility’s CEO. “That increase is less than half the rate of inflation since the 2021 test year used in our last rate case.”

What is ARAM?

Commissioners also voted to approve TEP’s annual rate adjustment mechanism, or ARAM, a formula that lets the utility adjust rates each year without undergoing a full rate case. TEP says the ARAM will smooth out bill changes between rate cases. Nearly every other party in the case opposed it, including the US Department of Defense, KJZZ reported.

Commissioner Lea Márquez Peterson was the sole vote against the increase, pointing to the ARAM for her vote.

“I think we each worked hard today and throughout this rate case to balance the interests of the company as well as the ratepayers,” Márquez Peterson said, the Arizona Capitol Times reported. “However, with the ARAM in place … I’m not comfortable with this rate case.”

Opponents said the ARAM risked reducing transparency when determining future hikes, but the board saw it differently: Commissioner Rachel Walden said the mechanism will provide more frequent review of rate increases.

Who’s pushing back?

Public Power for Tucson, a Tucson Democratic Socialists of America campaign pushing for a city-owned utility, criticized the vote in a statement.

“TEP’s unaffordable rate hike is further proof that we need a public power utility that simply exists to serve us electricity, not make profit for a Canadian corporation. Too many TEP customers already can’t afford the utility’s unreasonable rates, bloated by their extreme rate of profit,” the group said in a Nov. 17 statement. “When electricity is needed to survive the hot summer months, a rate hike can equal a death sentence.”

TEP is owned by Fortis, a Canadian utility holding company. Earlier this month, Tucson voters rejected Prop. 421, a 25-year city franchise deal with TEP, by about 10 points.

Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes, a Democrat and former corporation commissioner whose office intervened in the case to oppose the increase, criticized the all-Republican commission, arguing that residents would struggle with the now higher bills.

“This decision is a bad deal for ratepayers. Instead of saving customers $148 million per year, as my Office’s expert witness suggested, the ACC has chosen unnecessary rate increases and electric bill instability for TEP’s customers,” Mayes said in a Nov. 18 statement. “Every Arizonan should know the ACC decided to make it easier for TEP’s investors to earn a profit instead of siding with ratepayers struggling to make ends meet.”

Mayes also criticized the ARAM, which she said allows the company to seek uncapped rate increases once a year, up to five times before another general rate case.

The state’s Residential Utility Consumer Office is already challenging a similar formula in court, which the commission approved earlier this year for UNS Gas, another Fortis-owned utility.

What happens next?

The commission’s makeup is about to change. Two new commissioners, Clara Pratte and Jonathon Hill, both Democrats, are set to take office in January, ending Republicans’ full control over the commission. Pratte and Hill will replace outgoing Chairman Nick Myers, who lost in the Republican primary in July, and Commissioner Kevin Thompson, both Republicans.

The outgoing commission is expected to vote in December on Arizona Public Service’s request for a roughly 14% rate hike, which also includes a formula rate. If approved as requested, it would add about $240 a year to the average APS residential bill.

Keep The Copper Courier free for everyone

If you found this story useful, would you consider supporting The Copper Courier?

Every day, our team works to provide Arizonans with free, fact-based reporting about the issues, policies, and decisions shaping life across the state. We believe everyone deserves access to trustworthy local news—not just those who can afford a subscription.

That's why you'll never hit a paywall here (though we may ask you to sign up for our newsletter). But keeping our journalism free depends on readers who believe informed communities are worth investing in.

If our reporting has helped you better understand what's happening in Arizona, please consider making a donation today. Every contribution helps us continue reporting, informing, and serving communities across the state.

Jessica Swarner
Jessica Swarner Newsletter Editor
Support our team

Categories:

Authors

  • Sahara Sajjadi is the Political Correspondent for The Copper Courier and a lifelong Arizonan. She earned her master’s degree in journalism and mass communication from the Walter Cronkite School at Arizona State University.